Destination: Search
Great Rentals is part of HomeAway.com, the world's leading vacation rentals marketplace. Search over 170,000 vacation rentals properties now! Click here to see more Shelter Island Vacation Rentals

Shelter Island Rentals, Sleeps 5-8

Go to page 1 (1-19 of 19)
Sort by: Show rentals per page

Shelter Island Charming, Historic Cottage

  • 3 BR/2 BA Cottage (sleeps 6) Beach, Near The Ocean, Rural, Town, Village

Shelter Island Airy + Light Island Retreat, Walk to Sunset Beach

  • 3 BR/3 BA House (sleeps 7)
    $500/nt
    $3,000 - $3,500/wk
    per property, Beach, Resort, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, Parking

Shelter Island ROMANTIC Hamptons Beach Cottage! Seclusion, Waterfalls

  • 2 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath Cottage (sleeps 6)
    $335 - $495/nt
    $2,150 - $3,875/wk
    $6,975 - $13,050/month
    per property, limited accessibility, Beach, Near The Ocean, Resort, Town, Village, Waterfront, Private Pool, Lawn / Garden, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television

Shelter Island Tranquil Island Refuge Nestled Among Towering Trees and Near Private Beach

  • 3 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 6)
    $1,900 - $2,575/wk
    per property, Beach, Resort, Lawn / Garden, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Shelter Island Nature Lover's Delight!

  • 3 BR/2 BA, 1 half bath Cottage (sleeps 6) Rural, Private Pool, Lawn / Garden, pets considered, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television

Shelter Island Contemporary Home With Old Vocabulary In Walking Distance To Beaches

  • 4 BR/3 BA House (sleeps 8)
    $6,000 - $11,000/month
    per property, Beach, Lawn / Garden, Balcony, Fitness Room / Equipment, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television

Shelter Island Very elegant, with hot tub, large deck and lush landscape

  • 3 BR/3 BA House (sleeps 8)
    $2,500 - $3,500/wk
    $7,000 - $13,000/month
    per property, Resort, Jacuzzi, Lawn / Garden, Fitness Room / Equipment, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television

Shelter Island Contemporary luxury home with pool in the Heights

  • 4 BR/4 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 8)
    $7,000/wk
    $20,000/month
    per property, Near The Ocean, Lawn / Garden, terrace, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet, Television, DVD Player

Shelter Island Design and Comfort Come Together in this Island Beach Home

  • 3 BR/3 BA House (sleeps 7)
    $2,800 - $4,750/wk
    per property, Beach, Rural, Lawn / Garden, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Shelter Island Charming Water View Victorian ' Eden Roc ' in Park-like-Setting

  • 5 BR/4 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 6)
    $30,000 - $35,000/month
    per property, accept credit card, Beach, Resort, Tennis Court, Lawn / Garden, pets considered, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable
Back to Top

Shelter Island Two Acre Waterfront Estate with Renovated Historic Home, Shelter Island NY

  • 4 BR/3 BA House (sleeps 7)
    $10,000/wk
    $20,000 - $25,000/month
    per property, Beach, Resort, Rural, Waterfront, Communal Pool, Jacuzzi, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television

Shelter Island Rustic house w/ pool on 2 private acres

  • 3 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 6)
    $8,000 - $15,000/month
    per property, accept credit card, Beach, Town, Private Pool, Lawn / Garden, terrace, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable

Shelter Island Shelter Island Renovated Barn Hideaway Pool • Water Access • Hamptons

  • 2 BR/2 BA Barn (sleeps 6) Beach, Village, Private Pool, Lawn / Garden, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Shelter Island Relax by the Pool at This Comfortable 3 Bedroom Retreat

  • 3 BR/2 BA Cottage (sleeps 8) Private Pool, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, DVD Player

Shelter Island Waterfront Charmer on idyllic Shelter Island for summer rental

  • 3 BR/3 BA House (sleeps 8) Beach, Waterfront, Lawn / Garden, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Shelter Island Sun Worshipers Paradise

  • 3 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 6) Beach, Private Pool, Lawn / Garden, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Shelter Island Coecles Harbor Ram Island Waterfront Estate

  • 3 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 6) Rural, Waterfront, Lawn / Garden, terrace, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet, Television, DVD Player

Shelter Island Adorable Waterfront Cottage

  • 2 BR/1 BA (sleeps 6) Air Conditioning, Satellite / Cable, DVD Player, barbecue, Fireplace

Shelter Island Peace and Quiet on Shelter Island

  • 4 BR/2 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 8) Beach, Rural, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, Fireplace
Go to page 1 (1-19 of 19)

© 1996-Present HomeAway.com, Inc. All rights reserved.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of the GreatRentals.com Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.