Destination: Search
Great Rentals is part of HomeAway.com, the world's leading vacation rentals marketplace. Search over 170,000 vacation rentals properties now! Click here to see more Fire Island Vacation Rentals

Fire Island Home Rentals by Owner

Go to page 1 (1-39 of 39)
Sort by: Show rentals per page
SPECIAL OFFER! May 17 - June 27 On Sale! May 17 - June 27

Cherry Grove Exquisite Bay Front Home in Cherry Grove, Fire Island

  • 6 BR/2 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 16)
    $1,800 - $2,500/wk
    per property, accept credit card, Beach, Waterfront, Lawn / Garden, pets considered, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, Fireplace

Davis Park Comfortable Open Layout Beach House ..just steps from the Ocean

  • 3 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 8)
    $3,000/wk
    per property, wheelchair accessible, Beach, Near The Ocean, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue

Seaview Classic 5 br bayfront, Seaview Fire Island

  • 6 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 14)
    $250 - $650/nt
    $2,000 - $3,900/wk
    per property, limited accessibility, Near The Ocean, Waterfront, Lawn / Garden, pets considered, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Davis Park Charming family friendly beach house w/ Internet - July available, sleeps 6

  • 3 BR/1 BA House (sleeps 6)
    $2,200 - $2,750/wk
    per property, limited accessibility, Beach, Near The Ocean, Town, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Davis Park 4 bedroom beach cottage--minutes from the ocean and bay--great for families

  • 4 BR/1 BA House (sleeps 8)
    $2,300 - $2,800/wk
    per property, Beach, Near The Ocean, Television, DVD Player

Seaview Cozy Beach House in Seaview / Fire Island (steps to beach, sleeps up to 12)

  • 6 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 12)
    $2,750 - $5,000/wk
    per property, Beach, Near The Ocean, pets considered, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, barbecue, Fireplace

Davis Park great location--quiet, secluded and private

  • 3 BR/1 BA House (sleeps 6)
    $2,300 - $2,800/wk
    per property, wheelchair accessible, Beach, Near The Ocean, Television, DVD Player

Seaview 3BR beach house-perfect for a family w. young kids-NO WATER damage

  • 3 BR House (sleeps 6) Beach, Communal Pool, Balcony, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue

Water Island Magical, remote beach front property with 360-degree views

  • 4 BR/4 BA House (sleeps 8)
    $750 - $1,450/nt
    $4,000 - $14,300/wk
    per property, Beach, Waterfront, Lawn / Garden, Balcony, pets considered, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, Fireplace

Ocean Beach Beautiful newly renovated home, very close to ocean

  • 5 BR/2 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 10)
    $5,500/wk
    per property, Beach, Near The Ocean, Air Conditioning, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue
Back to Top

Davis Park Davis Park - I Gorgeous 5 BR Beach House w/ Pool 4th house from Ocean

  • 5 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 12)
    $3,500 - $6,300/wk
    per property, Beach, Near The Ocean, Private Pool, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue, Fireplace

Ocean Bay Park Contemporary Beach House with Vaulted Ceilings and Lots of Sunshine

  • 3 BR House (sleeps 7)
    $500/nt
    $2,000 - $3,500/wk
    $10,000 - $14,000/month
    per property, accept credit card, wheelchair accessible, Beach, Near The Ocean, Communal Pool, pets considered, Air Conditioning, Satellite / Cable, Television

Davis Park Big & Beautiful Luxury Home With Ocean And Bay Vistas

  • 4 BR/2 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 8) Beach, Near The Ocean, Waterfront, Jacuzzi, Lawn / Garden, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Ocean Beach Family Friendly

  • 3 BR House (sleeps 6)
    $3,400/wk
    per property, Beach, Near The Ocean, Village, Waterfront, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, Fireplace

Ocean Beach Beautiful & Clean Home Steps To Ocean, Long Stays Welcome!

  • 3 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 8)
    $6,500/wk
    $24,000/month
    per property, Beach, Near The Ocean, Air Conditioning, Internet, Television, DVD Player, Fireplace

Ocean Beach Steps from the Beach, Ready for the Summer

  • 4 BR/1 BA House (sleeps 7) Near The Ocean, Town, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Seaview Bayview-40' Pool & Central A/C 4BR/ 2b Sleeps 8 WBFPL

  • 4 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 8)
    $7,000 - $8,000/wk
    $25,000 - $30,000/month
    per property, Near The Ocean, Private Pool, Balcony, pets considered, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television

Ocean Beach Lovely Fire Island home very close to Ocean - NO HURRICANE DAMAGE

  • 3 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 6) Beach, Near The Ocean, Lawn / Garden, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, Fireplace

Ocean Bay Park Bright and Breezy Beach House in Ocean Bay Park

  • 3 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 9) Beach, Near The Ocean, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue, Fireplace

Davis Park THE SEA TRAIN- 4 Bedroom/2 full Bath Beach House Rental

  • 4 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 8) accept credit card, limited accessibility, Beach, Near The Ocean, Waterfront, Balcony, Satellite / Cable, DVD Player
Back to Top

Kismet New Fire Island Beach Home with Bay View in Family Community

  • 4 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 8) Beach, Near The Ocean, Tennis Court, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player

Lonelyville Fire Island, Tranquility, Beach, Spectacular Sunsets, Cozy and Comfortable

  • 3 BR/3 BA House (sleeps 10) Beach, Waterfront, Balcony, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue

Ocean Bay Park Huge Beautiful Beach House, near ocean

  • 5 BR/2 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 13) Beach, Near The Ocean, Air Conditioning, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue

Davis Park Wonderful, large beach house

  • 4 BR House (sleeps 8) Beach, Near The Ocean, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, Parking, barbecue

Seaview Luxury home with views of ocean and bay great location

  • 4 BR/3 BA House (sleeps 14) Beach, Near The Ocean, Jacuzzi, Tennis Court, Lawn / Garden, terrace, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet

Ocean Bay Park Marooned! Ideal Beach House--Just steps from the glorious Fire Island beaches!

  • 3 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 6) Beach, Near The Ocean, Lawn / Garden, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue

Davis Park 1 Week left 7/9-16:Rustic 2 story beachouse designed for comfort & pleasure

  • 5 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 15) Beach, Near The Ocean, Balcony, pets considered, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue, Fireplace

Ocean Bay Park Steps to the Ocean - Three Season Bliss- Sleeps 9

  • 4 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 9) Beach, Near The Ocean, Lawn / Garden, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue, Fireplace

Davis Park Spectacular 5BR 2.5BA 3 Level Home With Breathtaking Views

  • 5 BR/2 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 10) Beach, Near The Ocean, Satellite / Cable, Television, Fireplace

Davis Park Above the Trees! - Spacious beach home with vistas for family or small group

  • 4 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 9) Beach, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, Fireplace
Back to Top

Robbins Rest Gorgeous Oceanfront Home, Fabulous Views - FIRE ISLAND

  • 3 BR/1 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 5)
    $4,300/wk
    per property, Beach, Waterfront, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue, Fireplace

Fire Island Pines Beautiful Beach House with Huge Pool *Last Weeks Available in August/Sept/Oct

  • 3 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 6) accept credit card, Beach, Near The Ocean, Private Pool, Lawn / Garden, terrace, Balcony, Air Conditioning, Internet

Davis Park 3 BR, 2 Full Bath Beachhouse in Paradise within steps of the Ocean and Bay

  • 3 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 8) Beach, Near The Ocean, barbecue

Robbins Rest Spectacular Views, Oceanfront Beach House

  • 4 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 8)
    $3,300 - $5,100/wk
    $13,200 - $20,400/month
    per property, Beach, Near The Ocean, Town, Village, Waterfront, DVD Player, Parking, Fireplace

Ocean Bay Park Distinct Architectural House Overlooking Ocean & Bay

  • 5 BR/2 BA, 1 half bath House (sleeps 10) Balcony, pets considered, Internet, Satellite / Cable, Television

Davis Park Lovely Beach Home new to rental market

  • 4 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 8) Beach, Near The Ocean, Air Conditioning, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, Fireplace

Davis Park Seconds to Ocean... A Minute to Bay... Upper Deck Echos Ocean Sounds..

  • 4 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 10) Beach, Near The Ocean, DVD Player, barbecue

Davis Park Oceanfront House in Davis Park

  • 4 BR/2 BA House (sleeps 8) pets considered, Air Conditioning

Davis Park 6 bedroom, 4 bathroom Ocean View Beach House

  • 6 BR/4 BA House (sleeps 12) Beach, Near The Ocean, pets considered, Satellite / Cable, Television, DVD Player, barbecue
Go to page 1 (1-39 of 39)

© 1996-Present HomeAway.com, Inc. All rights reserved.

Use of this Web site constitutes acceptance of the GreatRentals.com Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.